Our Genealogy
 
 
Our Families
Family Trees
Acknowledgments
Contact Us
Surname Index

 

 

Phoebe Carico
1860 - 1892

   

 
Father Birth Death  
James Levi Carico 1836, Louisville, KY, son of James William Carico and ?Elizabeth Littlejohn Unknown m1. May 26, 1857, Goodhue Township, Goodhue Co., MN
 
Mother Birth Death  
Caroline Kittle Dec 1839, Randolph Co., VA Nov 1, 1928, Rochester, Monroe Co., NY. 

Buried somewhere in Cleveland, Cuyahoga Co., OH
m2. William Harrison Thomas - ( b. 1842, Greenup Co., KY, son of William Thomas and Harriet Brackett ; d. bef 1890  ) - Jun 27, 1872, Catlettsburg, Boyd Co., KY
 

Siblings of Phoebe Carico
select a name below to view their information

Same father -- James Levi Carico

1/2 Siblings -- father William Harrison Thomas

John William Carico Phoebe Carico Nancy Carico James Morris Carico Emma F Carico
Hattie Thomas Elizabeth "Libby" Thomas William Henry Thomas Birdie Thomas
 
  Birth Death Notes
Phoebe Carico ca Apr 1860, IN d. Jun 19, 1892, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV.

Unknown burial location.  Strong possibility that it is Spring Hill Cemetery. Grandmother Phoebe Ellen Phillips Kittle is buried there along with husband Marion.  Although, Marion is probably buried by himself.  Children did not know who their mother was on all three death certificates so they would not know to bury Marion with Phoebe if she was there.
m. Marion Pascal Arthur - ( b. Mar 22, 1860, Cabell Co., WV, son of Pinell F Arthur and Virginia Davis ; d. Feb 18, 1924, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV.  Buried at Spring Hill Cemetery, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV  ) - Dec 24, 1880, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV
 

Children of  Phoebe Carico and Marion Pascal Arthur
Select a name below to jump to the section of the page with their information

Rosa Ellen Arthur Garland George Arthur Sallie Arthur Alice Arthur Cline Arthur
 
Phoebe Carico
  1860 - 1870 - Census - Living with parents
 
1860 U. S. Census, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana  See Census
Name   Race Gender Age Occupation Birth Place
Carico James W M 24 Laborer
KY
  Caroline W F 20   VA
  John W M 2   WI
  Phoebe W F 2/12   IN
 
1870 U. S. Census, District 4, Boyd County, Kentucky   See Census
Name   Race Gender Age Occupation Birth Place
Carico Caroline W F 30 Assists in house keeping VA
  John W M 11 Laborer WI
  Phoeba W F 9 At home IN
  Nancy   F 8 At home IN
  Emma W F 4 At home WV
  1880 - Census - Living with maternal grandparents
 
1880 U. S. Census, Huntington, Cabell County, West Virginia  See Census
Name   Relation Race Gender Age Occupation Birth Place Birth Place
Father
Birth Place
Mother
Kittle Thomas B Husband W M 60 Farmer WV WV WV
  Phoeba Wife W F 62 Keeping house WV WV WV
  James Son W M 19 Laborer OH WV WV
Carico John Gr son W M 21 Laborer WI IN WV
  Phoeba Gr dau W F 19 At home IN IN WV
Kittle Charles H Gr son W M 9   KY OH KY
 
1880 - Marries Marion Pascal Arthur, Dec 24, 1880, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV

Marriage record for Phoebe Carico and Marion Pascal Arthur (#2 on list)

Select the image to see a larger version
  1892 - Phoebe passes away on Jun 19, 1892.  On the same date, she gives birth to son Cline.  The death record says she died from consumption.  It was probably a combination of child birth and the TB.  Also, on this death record is the death of her son Cline at 2 months from the same cause.  Of note is the 2 months.  The birth record for Cline Arthur is indexed under Jan 19, 1892.  This is supposed to be Jun 19, 1892.  If Cline had been born in Jan, he would have been 8 months old at death, not 2.
 
1892 - Phoebe Carico Arthur passes away, Jun 19, 1892, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV

Death record for Phoebe Carico Arthur

Select the image to see a larger version
  Unknown burial location for Phoebe.  Strong possibility that it is Spring Hill Cemetery. Grandmother Phoebe Ellen Phillips Kittle is buried there along with husband Marion.  Although, Marion is probably buried by himself.  Children did not know who their mother was on all three death certificates, so they would not know to bury Marion with Phoebe, if she was there.
 
1893
- Widower Marion marries Anna --? born Oct 1861, OH, ca 1893
 
 
1900 U. S. Census, Guyandotte, Cabell County, West Virginia  See Census
Name   Rel Race Gen Birth
Mon
Birth
Year
Age Yrs
Marr.
# Child #Ch
living
Occup Birth Place Birth Place
Fath
Birth Place
Moth
Arthur Marion Head W M Mar 1858 42 M-7     Farmer WV WV WV
  Anna Wife W F Oct 1861 38 M-7 0 0   OH OH OH
  Garland Son W F Apr 1884 16 S     At school WV WV OH
  Sallie Dau W F Jun 1887 13 S     At school WV WV OH
  1900 - 1908 - Divorces or is widowed again by Anna--?
 
  1908 - Marion marries widow Mary Stapleton Howard, Oct 16, 1908, Cabell Co., WV.  In the 1910 Census there are two children with the last name of Howard from previous marriage to Whitt Howard; Ida Mae Howard and Roscoe Stapleton Howard.
 
  1920 - Census - Marion living with wife Mary Stapleton and her son Roscoe in Guyandotte, Cabell Co., WV
 
  1920 - 1922 - Divorces Mary Stapleton or she passes away
 
  1922 - Marion marries Juanita Nervetta "Nettie" Wellman Maynard, Jul 8, 1922, Cabell Co., WV.  She was wife of Harrison D Maynard who died in 1914.  Juanita dies in 1961 under last name Maynard.
 
1924 - Marion Pascal Arthur passes away, Feb 18, 1924, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV

Death certificate for Marion Arthur

Select the image to see a larger version
   
Children of Phoebe Carico and Marion Pascal Arthur
   
  Rosa Ellen Arthur - b. Jun 21, 1882, Cabell Co., WV ; d. Apr 15, 1959, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV.  Buried at White Chapel Memorial Gardens, Barboursville, Cabell Co., WV.

m.
Alexander Gibson - ( b. Sep 3, 1872, Wayne Co., WV, son of Elijah Gibson and Katherine Burke ; d. Sep 26, 1951, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV.  Buried at Gibson Cemetery, Huntington, Wayne Co., WV.  Married first to Elizabeth Earls, 1895, Wayne Co., WV, d. bef 1900 and had son Delbert Gibson, 1896-1962 . Married second to Eliza Jane Jackson, 1901, Lawrence Co., OH, d. bef 1910 and had sons Wilbert Curtis Gibson, 1902-1968,  Eligah Gibson 1905-1970, and Isaac Pierce Gibson, 1908-1955 ) - Jul 13, 1911, Cabell Co., WV
 
Rosa Ellen Arthur
  Rose never appears in the Census with her parents
  1900 - Census - Living as a servant at age 17 in the home of Louisa Bledsoe in Huntington, Cabell Co., WV
  1910 - Census - Living as a servant at age 26 in the home of Elzie Holderby in Huntington, Cabell Co., WV along with her son Ernest age 1     See Census
 
1911 - Marries twice widowed Alexander Gibson,  Jul 13, 1911, Cabell Co., WV

Marriage Record for Rosa Arthur and Alex Gipson [stet]   #6

Select the image to see a larger version
  1920 - Census - For some reason, infant son Walter is missing on this Census.  Staying somewhere else???
 
1920 U. S. Census, Huntington, Cabell County, West Virginia  See Census
Name   Rel Race Gen Age Marr? Occup Birth Place Birth Place
Father
Birth Place
Mother
Gibson Ellick Head W M 47 M Laborer Glass Co WV WV WV
  Rosa Wife W F 36 M   WV WV USA
  Curtis Son W M 17 S Laborer Glass Co WV WV USA
  Eligah Son W M 14 S   WV WV WV
  Pierce Son W M 11 S   WV WV WV
Johnson Ernest Step-Son W M 11 S   WV WV WV
 
1930 - Census - Unable to locate family in this Census.  Tried searching under each first name also.  However, the Huntington City Directory does show them living there in 1930 at 1506 Harrison Ave.  Page 316 of this directory has neighbors of this address such as Emmett H Lushbaugh.  None appear in 1930 Census.  I can only assume this section of street was missed in this census.

1930 City Directory for Huntington, WV

Look under Alex Gibson

Select the image to see a larger version
 
1940 U. S. Census, Huntington, Cabell County, West Virginia   See Census
Name   Rel. Race Gen Age Marr? Highest grade of school completed Occup. Birth Place
Gibson Alex Head W M 66 M 0   WV
  Rose Wife W F 56 M 3   WV
  Walter Wife W F 20 S 8 Laborer NYA WV
  Boyd Wife W F 17 S 8   WV
  1950 - Census - Rosa and Alex together with one lodger in Huntington, WV, living on 1931 James River Road
 
1951 - Alexander Gibson passes away, Sep 26, 1951, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV

Death Certificate for Alex Gibson

Select the image to see a larger version
 
1959 - Rosa Ellen Arthur Gibson passes away, Apr 15, 1959, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV

Death Certificate for Rosa Ellen Gibson

Select the image to see a larger version
   
  Ernest Johnson - b. May 11, 1908, WV ; d. May 26, 1924, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV.  Buried at Spring Hill Cemetery, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV       
 
Ernest Johnson
  1910 - Census - Living with his mother under name Ernest Arthur
  1920 - Census - Living with parents under the name Ernest Johnson
 
1924 - Ernest Johnson passes away,  May 26, 1924, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV

Death Certificate for Earnest Johnson, indexed under Earnest Jahnsam

Select the image to see a larger version
   
Children of Rosa Ellen Arthur and Alexander Gibson
   
  Walter Jacob Gibson - b. Sep 26, 1919, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV ; d. Jul 4, 2011, Tampa, Hillsborough Co., FL.  Buried at Sunset Memory Gardens, Thonotosassa, Hillsborough Co., FL

m.
Dorothy Helen Brault - ( ca 1914, Windsor, Ontario, Canada, daughter of Harry Brault and Marie Morash ; d. ???   Married first to Harold Lenz, 1946, Detroit, MI  ) - Aug 2, 1948, Detroit, Wayne Co., MI
 
Walter Jacob Gibson
 

Birth record for Walter Jacob Gibson

Select the image to see a larger version
  1920 - Census - For some reason, Walter was not listed with family.  Missed or perhaps staying with a grandparent?  He was only around 6 months old at this time.
  1930 - Census - Family missed in this Census
  1940 - Census - Living with parents
 

WWII Registration for Walter Jacob Gibson

Select the image to see a larger version
  WWII - Fought in WWII in Army Air Forces
  1948 - Marries Dorothy Helen Brault Lenz, Aug 2, 1948, Detroit, Wayne Co., MI
  1950 - Census - Living with wife Dorothy in Detroit.
  Unknown if marriage to Dorothy lasted or if there were any children.
  1975 - 2011 - At some point Walter moves to Tampa.  Earliest record in Directories is 1975
  2011 - There was only a death notice for Walter with burial location.  No other personal info.
 

Grave marker for Walter Jacob Gibson at Buried at Sunset Memory Gardens, Thonotosassa, Hillsborough Co., FL

Photo taken by Deborah Stanley a volunteer at the
Find A Grave website

Select the image to see a larger version
   
  Boyd Gibson - b. Apr 10, 1922, WV ; d. Apr 29, 2003, Youngstown, Mahoning Co., OH

m.
Anna M Carter - ( b. Apr 16, 1925, Youngstown, Mahoning Co., OH, daughter of Andrew Carter and Emma F Lape  ; d. Apr 16, 2011, OH  ) -

Buried together at New Four Mile Cemetery, Austintown, Mahoning Co., OH
 
Boyd Gibson
 

Birth record for Boyde [stet] Gibson

Select the image to see a larger version
  1940 - Census - Living with parents
 

WWII Registration for Boyd Gibson

Select the image to see a larger version
  1943 - 1945 - Enlisted in Army Jun 7, 1943 at Akron, OH.  Discharged Sep 1, 1945
 
1950 U. S. Census, Youngstown, Mohoning County, Ohio       See Census
Name   Rel. Race Gen Age Marr? Birth Place Occup.
Carter Andrew Head W M 52 M OH Laborer Steel mill
  Emma F Wife W F 46 M PA Waitress Restaurant
Gibson Boyd Son in law W M 27 M WV Stationary Engineer Steel mill
  Anna M Dau W F 24 M OH  
  Boyd E Gr Son W M 2 Nev OH  
 
Obituary for Anna Gibson
https://www.higgins-reardon.com/obituaries/anna-gibson
Accessed December 6, 2024
AUSTINTOWN - Funeral services will be held Monday at noon at the Higgins-Reardon Funeral Homes, Austintown Chapel for Anna Gibson, 86, who passed away Saturday morning.

Anna was born April 16, 1925, in Youngstown, the daughter of Andrew and Emma Carter, and was a lifelong area resident of Austintown.

She attended Chaney High School and was a homemaker. She was a member of the Four Mile Run Christian Church and Daughters of America and Dames of Malta.

She leaves to cherish her memory, her son, Boyd of Panama City, Fla.; her daughter, Patricia Gibson and son Walter of Austintown; one granddaughter, Kay Sutton from Port Charlotte, Fla.; one grandson, Jason Gibson from Panama City; two great-grandsons, Andrew and Logan Gibson of Panama City; one great-granddaughter, Jessica; and two great-grandsons, Nathan and Matthew Sutton of Port Charlotte.

She was preceded in death by her husband, Boyd Gibson; one sister, Mary McCullough; and brother Evan Carter.

The family requests that memorial tributes take the form of contributions in Ann's name to St. Elizabeth Diabetes Education.
 

Grave markers for Boyd Gibson and Anna M Carter at New Four Mile Cemetery, Austintown, Mahoning Co., OH

Photos taken by Harry Turner a volunteer at the
Find A Grave website

Select the image to see a larger version
   
Children of Boyd Gibson and Anna M Carter
   
  Boyd Eugene Gibson - b. Nov 13, 1947, OH

m.
Carol Anne Rahe - ( b. Mar 4, 1946, Fresno Co., CA, daughter of Stanley Thurber Rahe and Viola Vater   ) -
 
Boyd Eugene Gibson
 
Yearbook photo Boyd Gibson
1965 - Austintown Fitch High School, Youngstown, OH
  Kay Lynn Gibson - b. Aug 13, 1970, Campbell Co., KY   

m.
Charles David Sutton, Jr - ( b. Mar 29, 1966, IN, son of Charles David Sutton and Deanna Lynn Throckmartin  ) - Nov 18, 1989, Lena, Vigo Co., IN  
      
m. Clark??
 
Kay Lynn Gibson
   
  Jessica Nichole Sutton - b. Jul 16, 1989              North Port, FL
  Nathaniel David Sutton - b. Nov 14, 1994                  North Port, FL

m.
Shelley Ann Hughston - ( b. Jul 22, 1996, FL, daughter of Robert Adams Hughston and Wanda Gail Dixon   ) -                have daughter
  Matthew Allen Sutton - b. Oct 1996                   Port Charlotte, FL    Has criminal record
  Jason Scott Gibson - b. Mar 16, 1974, Kenton Co., KY               Redding, CA

m.
Kristen Anne Hansen - ( b. Jun 15, 1974              ) -
 
Jason Scott Gibson
   
  Andrew S Gibson - b. Feb 2003
  Logan Gibson - b. 2006                  Down Syndrome
   
  Patricia Ann Gibson - b. Feb 1, 1951, OH
 
Patricia Ann Gibson
 
Yearbook photo Patricia Ann Gibson
1973 - Youngstown State University, Youngstown, OH
   
  Walter Alan Gibson - b. Aug 1, 1956, OH ; d. 2022, Middleburg Heights, Cuyahoga Co., OH
 
Walter Alan Gibson
 
Yearbook photo Walter Gibson
1974 - Austintown Fitch High School, Youngstown, OH
   
   
   
  Garland George Arthur - b. Feb 21, 1884, Cabell Co., WV ; d. Sep 28, 1969, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV

m.
Maggie Mae Beckett - ( b. Jan 17, 1890, Milton, Cabell Co., WV, daughter of George Martin Beckett and Mary Ann Meadows ; d. Sep 6, 1938, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV  ) - May 2, 1905, Catlettsburg, Boyd Co., KY

Buried together at Earl Cemetery, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV
 
     Marriage and Children of Garland George Arthur.....
 
  Sallie Arthur - b. Nov 13, 1885 or 1886, Cabell Co., WV ; d. Jun 20, 1962, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV

m.
Colonel Henson Perdue - ( b. Mar 13, 1882, Wayne Co., WV, son of  Andrew Jackson Perdue and Nancy Jane Ross ; d. Feb 27, 1969, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV ) - Mar 20, 1904, Cabell Co., WV

Buried together at Crook Chapel Cemetery, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV
 
     Marriage and Children of Sallie Arthur.....
 
  Alice Arthur - b. Cabell Co., WV ; d. Aug 1890
 
Alice Arthur
 

Death Record for Alice Arthur

Select the image to see a larger version
   
  Cline Arthur - b. Jun 19, 1892, Cabell Co., WV ; d. Aug 23, 1892, Huntington, Cabell Co., WV
 
Cline Arthur
 

Birth Record for Cline Arthur

Select the image to see a larger version
 

Death Record for Cline Arthur  ( under mother's name )

Select the image to see a larger version
   
   
 
 
1900 U. S. Census, St. George, Tucker County, West Virginia  See Census
Name   Rel Race Gen Birth
Mon
Birth
Year
Age Yrs
Marr.
# Child #Ch
living
Occup Birth Place Birth Place
Fath
Birth Place
Moth
    Head W M             Farming WV WV WV
    Wife W F                    
1910 U. S. Census, St, Randolph County, West Virginia  See Census
Name   Rel. Race Gen. Age Yrs
Marr.
# Child #
Child
living
Occup. Birth Place Birth Place
Fath
Birth Place
Moth
    Head W M         Farmer / Farm WV WV WV
Wife W F      
W F      
1920 U. S. Census, D, Randolph County, West Virginia  See Census
Name   Rel Race Gen Age Marr? Occup Birth Place Birth Place
Father
Birth Place
Mother
    Head W M       WV WV WV
    Wife W F       WV WV WV
    Son W M       WV WV WV
    Dau W F       WV WV WV
1930 U. S. Census,              West Virginia   See Census
Name   Rel. Race Gen Age Age 1st
Marr.
Occup Birth Place Birth Place
Father
Birth Place
Mother
    Head W M     Laborer coal mine WV WV WV
    Wife W F       WV WV WV
1940 U. S. Census,                  West Virginia   See Census
Name   Rel. Race Gen Age Marr? Highest grade of school completed Occup. Birth Place
    Head W M         WV
    Wife W F         WV
 
1950 U. S. Census,         West Virginia   See Census
Name   Rel. Race Gen Age Marr? Birth Place Occup.
    Head W M        
    Wife W F        
 

 

Grave marker for                             at

Photo taken by B a volunteer at the
Find A Grave website

Select the image to see a larger version
 
Obituary for
 
 
 
   
   
 
 
   
   
 
 
   
   
 
 
   
   
 
 
   
 
 
May 26, 2025